Photodynamic Remediation of Black Stain

Overview

This study investigates the remediation of black-stained tooth surfaces using antimicrobial photodynamic therapy. In this crossover trial, a cohort of patients received standard dental prophylactic cleaning to remove the black stain. Later, following the washout period, (reappearance of the black stain) received photodynamic therapy in addition to the standard cleaning. Stain-free period in each of the arms was the main outcome variable. Additional microbial plaque testing was also carried out.

Full Title of Study: “Remediation of Adult Black Dental Stains by Photodynamic Therapy”

Study Type

• Study Type: Interventional
• Study Design
  • Allocation: Non-Randomized
  • Intervention Model: Crossover Assignment
  • Primary Purpose: Treatment
  • Masking: None (Open Label)
• Study Primary Completion Date: April 30, 2016

Detailed Description

The standard treatment practice for black dental stain is dental prophylaxis, however this is often harmful to the enamel surface and can result in tooth sensitivity. In this study we aim to explore the application of antimicrobial photodynamic therapy (aPDT) for the treatment of adult black dental stain. aPDT has demonstrated positive results in the treatment of periodontitis. Patients received an oral examination and the extent of black stain was scored (score 1, pigmented spots or incomplete lines parallel to the gingival margin, score 2: solid lines pigmented, readily observable and limited to the cervical third of the tooth surface, score 3: pigmentation extending beyond the cervical third). The patients' oral cavity was photographed in sextants, along with a complete picture of the jaw (lingual plane) and the maxillary arch (palatal plane). For bacterial analysis, 1mg of black plaque was collected by scraping with a plastic scaler from buccal tooth surfaces taking care to avoid unnecessary removal of enamel hydroxyapatite. The first dental prophylaxis was performed to remove the black stain. Patients were reviewed monthly and in each visit, were photographed as previously described, and the level of pigmentation scored according to the mentioned criteria. The monthly visits were continued until the black stain score returned to the initial value. The period between the first and the last appointment was noted. At this point, each volunteer received dental prophylaxis once again, followed by the application of aPDT. Antimicrobial photodynamic therapy was applied to 31 orally healthy volunteers with black stained teeth, using the GLO home whitening device (GLO™ Science LLC, New York, USA) in 2 cycles of 8 minutes. Outcome variables were area, color and time taken to reappearance of black stain following dental prophylaxis with and without antimicrobial photodynamic therapy. Differences in bacterial composition of black stain (specifically Aggregatibacter actinomycetemcomitans, Tannerella forsythia and Porphyromonas gingivalis) were analyzed DNA extracted from plaque samples. Following the application of aPDT, patients were reviewed monthly until the black stain score returned to the initial value.

Interventions

• Procedure: Dental prophylaxis
  • American Dental Association, Code on Dental Procedures and Nomenclature (CDT) CDT code D1110
• Device: Dental prophylaxis + antimicrobial photodynamic therapy
  • Dental prophylaxis using American Dental Association, Code on Dental Procedures and Nomenclature (CDT) CDT code D1110 followed by two 8-minute irradiation cycles using GLO Brilliant home use whitening device (GLO ™ Science LLC, New York, USA).

Arms, Groups and Cohorts

• Active Comparator: Dental Prophylaxis
  • Standard dental prophylaxis
• Active Comparator: Dental prophylaxis + antimicrobial photodynamic therapy
  • Dental prophylaxis + aPDT

Clinical Trial Outcome Measures

Primary Measures

• Restoration period
  • Time Frame: The period of time required for the restoration of the black stain to pre-cleaning levels will be determined by measurements carried out during Weeks 18-24, post-application of each treatment arm
  • Time to restoration of the black stain following each treatment arm

Secondary Measures

• Black stain color
  • Time Frame: The depth of color of the black stain will be measured at Week 20 following the application of each treatment arm
  • Color of the black stain
• Black stain area
  • Time Frame: Area covered by the black stain will be carried out at Week 20 following the application of each treatment arm
  • Area covered by the black stain
• Microbial composition
  • Time Frame: Black plaque sampling will be carried out at Week 0, followed by a second sampling at Week 20, following the application of each treatment arm, in accordance with the reappearance rate of the black stain in each study volunteer
  • Microbial composition of the black plaque

Participating in This Clinical Trial

Inclusion Criteria

• Volunteers with black stained (plaque on) teeth Exclusion Criteria:

• Children – Pregnant women – Volunteers having completed antibiotic therapy during 15 days prior to the start of the study

Gender Eligibility: All

Minimum Age: 18 Years

Maximum Age: N/A

Are Healthy Volunteers Accepted: Accepts Healthy Volunteers

Investigator Details

• Lead Sponsor
  • Cardenal Herrera University
• Provider of Information About this Clinical Study
  • Principal Investigator: Chirag Sheth, Associate Professor – Cardenal Herrera University
• Overall Official(s)
  • Maria del Mar Jovani Sancho, PhD, Study Director, Cardenal Herrera University