Lymphedema (significant arm swelling on the surgical side) is one of the most common complications following treatment for breast cancer. The impact of lymphedema is profound, resulting in negative self image, increased anxiety and poorer quality of life. In time, lymphedema can result in recurrent infections in the arm, functional impairment and pain. Approximately 21% of women who undergo breast cancer treatment develop lymphedema. Unfortunately this is a life-time condition which tends to worsen over time. Currently, treatment consists of intensive physiotherapy, meant to reduce the arm volume followed by the wearing of compression sleeves during the day for maintenance. This study hopes to show that the addition of night-time compression creates a measurable reduction in arm volume and that adding night-time compression to the standard care (daytime compression only) will produce improvements in quality of life for breast cancer survivors.
Full Title of Study: “Night-time Compression for Breast Cancer Related Lymphedema (LYNC): A Randomized Controlled Efficacy Trial”
- Study Type: Interventional
- Study Design
- Allocation: Randomized
- Intervention Model: Crossover Assignment
- Primary Purpose: Treatment
- Masking: Single (Outcomes Assessor)
- Study Primary Completion Date: May 2018
Lymphedema is a lifetime condition which tends to worsen over time, affecting roughly 21% of of treated breast cancer patients. An initial intensive rehabilitative treatment is usually prescribed to reduce the lymphedema, followed by a maintenance program using compression sleeves (Standard Care). However, compression sleeves are prescribed for daytime use only due to the potential tourniquet effect of the sleeve rolling up or bunching during the night.
Compression Bandages (short stretch, low elasticity) can be used at night but proper application takes 20-30 minutes, require skill to apply properly and are costly. Various types of night-compression system garments (NCSGs) have been designed as alternatives to Compression Bandages (CB).
The objectives of this study are to determine:
1. Whether the addition of night-time compression (using CB or NCSG) to standard care (daytime compression only) improves control of arm lymphedema.
2. Whether the use of NCSGs result in better outcomes in quality of life, sleep, treatment compliance and patient independence than use of Compression Bandages.
The hypotheses are that:
1. Standard care plus the addition of NCSG will provide statistically significant improvement in management of arm lymphedema volume compared to standard care alone at 12 weeks.
2. Standard care plus the addition of Compression Bandages will provide statistically significant improved management of arm lymphedema volume compared to standard care alone at 12 weeks.
3. Standard care plus the addition of NCSG will provide statistically significant benefit in quality of life, sleep and self-efficacy over standard care plus Compression Bandaging at 12 weeks.
Group 1: Standard care weeks 1 – 12 Group 2: Standard care plus night-time Compression Bandaging weeks 1 – 12 Group 3: Standard care plus night-time use of NCSG weeks 1 – 12
All three groups will adopt NCSG use after the 12 week assessments have been done (weeks 13 – 24).
Sample size = 40 participants per group, for a total of 120 patients at three sites.
Participants will be randomized in a 1:1:1 ratio to Standard, CB or NCSG using a secure central randomization service administered by the Clinical Trials Unit of the Cross Cancer Institute. Women enrolled in the study will be stratified by accruing site and by lymphedema severity (i.e. mild versus moderate lymphedema as per the classification criteria of the International Society of Lymphology).
Arm volume (by Perometer) and arm fluid (by Bioimpedance analysis) will be measured and compared to that of the unaffected arm. BIA measures the impedance of flow from a low alternating electrical current that is applied to the body through a skin electrode. BIA records impedance values for each limb and provides an index that correlates with quantitative measurements of volume increase in limb size seen in the arm with lymphedema. This measurement will provide information on extracellular fluid changes that complements the data on arm lymphedema volume. An Independent Assessor unaware of treatment allocation (blinded) will perform the measurements of arm volume using the perometer, bioimpedance analysis, and body weight at baseline, 6, 12, 18 and 24 weeks. The duration of the primary intervention will be 12 weeks. Following the 12-week intervention period, participants in the CB and standard care groups will be measured for a NCSG.
The follow-up period after the intervention (weeks 13 to 24) will follow a longitudinal observational design and provide an opportunity to examine factors related to long-term adherence to night-time compression. Lymphedema specific questionnaires and subject diary will be completed at 6, 12, 18 and 24 weeks to assess subject's Quality of Life, sleep disturbance, self-efficacy and treatment adherence.
- Device: Night-time compression bandages
- Daytime compression sleeve plus night-time compression by self-administered or assisted multi-layered compression bandages.
- Device: Compression Sleeve, daytime wear
- Device: Night-time Compression custom-made garment
- Standard Care plus night-time compression by a custom-made night time compression system garment.
Arms, Groups and Cohorts
- Active Comparator: Standard care
- Weeks 1-12, Standard Care only (Compression Sleeve, daytime wear)
- Experimental: Standard Care plus Night-time Compression Bandages
- Weeks 1 – 12, Daytime compression sleeve plus night-time compression by self-administered or assisted multi-layered Compression Bandages.
- Experimental: Standard Care Plus Night-time Compression System Garment
- Weeks 1 – 12, Standard care (day-time sleeve) plus night-time use of a custom-made Night-time Compression System Garment
Clinical Trial Outcome Measures
- Arm volume. Lymphedema will be objectively measured using the Perometer (Pero-systems, Wipputal, Germany)
- Time Frame: 12 weeks
- Arm fluid. Bioimpedance analysis (BIA) will be used to assess extracellular fluid status within the arm
- Time Frame: 12 weeks
Participating in This Clinical Trial
- Histological diagnosis of breast cancer with mild to moderate lymphedema (minimum of 200 mls or 10% and maximum 40% increase in arm volume over the unaffected arm.)
- Completion of all primary and adjuvant cancer treatments (with exception of endocrine treatment) 1 month prior to randomization.
- In or entering upon the maintenance phase of lymphedema treatment.
- Have properly fitted day-time compression sleeve and agree to wear sleeve for the 12 hour per day standard of care period
- No current use of night-time compression (one month wash-out period before trial entry)
- Clinical or radiological evidence of active disease, either local or metastatic
- History or clinical diagnosis of bilateral arm lymphedema
- Anyone for whom compression is contraindicated, such as those with untreated infections, skin irritations/rash, or thrombosis of the affected arm
- Serious non-malignant disease or any disorder/circumstance (psychiatric or addictive disorder) which would preclude consent/adherence to the protocol
- Unable to comply with the protocol, measurement and follow-up schedule due to factors such as vacation during the study period
Gender Eligibility: Female
Minimum Age: N/A
Maximum Age: N/A
Are Healthy Volunteers Accepted: No
- Lead Sponsor
- AHS Cancer Control Alberta
- Cross Cancer Institute
- Provider of Information About this Clinical Study
- Overall Official(s)
- Margaret McNeely, PhD, Principal Investigator, Cross Cancer Institute
Clinical trials entries are delivered from the US National Institutes of Health and are not reviewed separately by this site. Please see the identifier information above for retrieving further details from the government database.